Hello Yellow Army!
Let me pinch myself, because for a moment I felt I was back in my college internship days of 2019! After watching just the first over of today's 4th ODI between India and New Zealand, it all came rushing back, and I could not stop reliving those memories of that semi-final morning.
I was actually excited to watch it today, because our Ruturaj Gaikwad had finally got a chance to play and even open the innings, in the absence of Shubman Gill, who sat out to prepare for the Tests. But in my wildest imagination, I never thought I would witness a disaster collapse of India like this.
This is an opinion piece, so I will be upfront: it was a brilliant spell, and I also think nobody should rush to conclusions about what it means for CSK. Let me explain both.
Matt Henry vs India, 4th ODI: 6/27 and a Triple-Wicket Maiden
In the first two ODIs, New Zealand rarely got a good start, as our Indian bowlers troubled them enough to bundle them out for under 200 and win both matches. Then the 3rd ODI was washed out by rain, which maybe gave them the time to replan and strategise, and with the players also reshuffled for the upcoming Test matches, this time they got an 85-run opening partnership in 12 overs and went well above expectations to a very good, competitive 333.
Henry even added 2 off 2 balls with the bat, and I am sure he thought, "okay, that is my contribution done, let me go and rest."
Then Henry took the new ball and did not waste a single minute. Right in the first over, the ball jumped a bit extra and moved away from Rohit Sharma. It was not even quick, around 127 kph, but it found the thick edge, and Finn Allen at first slip dived to his left and held on to it. Rohit walked back for a golden duck, his second duck in this series. I thought okay, maybe just one of those bad days for him.
Then our king Virat Kohli walked in, and I was ready for fireworks. But Henry kept pitching it up, and on the 5th ball a good length delivery stayed low and nipped back in. Kohli just left it, and the next thing he saw was the ball going through the gap between bat and pad and hitting the stumps. He stood there in disbelief! What more do you want from a first over? Two pillars of the Indian batting gone on ducks, and that rarely happens.
But Henry was still not done with this over. Shreyas Iyer came in, and the last ball was another sharp in-swinger on a good length. He tried to defend from the crease, missed the inside edge, and was trapped LBW. That is the triple-wicket maiden, with Rohit, Kohli and Iyer all on golden ducks.
India were 0/3 already, like a football scoreline, and our CSK captain Ruturaj Gaikwad also went early for 5. Should I also talk about our CSK captain, for whom it could have been another good opportunity to stand up? Well, I am not in the mood today, so let's wait for the last ODI.
There was no time to breathe for India. When Henry came back for his second spell in the 21st over, he struck on the very first ball and removed the batter who had looked the best, India's highest scorer with 27 - Ishan Kishan. He took his 5th wicket in the very next over.
And finally, it was Gurnoor Brar's turn, bowled by Henry, and it was only fitting that he finished the innings himself, with 6/27 in 9.4 overs with 2 maidens. India were bowled out for just 89 in 26.4 overs, and New Zealand won by 244 runs. Matt Henry was Player of the Match, and as you can see in his tracker entry for the 4th ODI, nobody was complaining.
It is also a spell for the record books, because it is his fourth five-wicket haul in ODIs, which puts him level with Shane Bond for the most ODI 5-fers by a New Zealander after Trent Boult (6) and Sir Richard Hadlee (5).
The 2019 Semi-Final, Again
Let me take you back to that day properly. New Zealand finished on 239/8, which at first looked like a below-par total, but not so much when you consider that it was an important knockout semi-final of a World Cup.
And then Henry started hunting right from his first over, taking down Rohit Sharma, the man in form and the top scorer of that World Cup. In his second over, he got KL Rahul, and India were left at 5/3, with Rohit, Virat Kohli and Rahul all on one run each. Then he continued breaking the hopes of Indian fans one by one, getting Dinesh Karthik in his 5th over, before he gave us a breather at the end of his long first spell: 7-1-23-3, with India at 42/4.
He finished with 3/37 and the Player of the Match award. India needed 240 and were bowled out for 221, losing by 18 runs.
What saved the pride of that day was a 116-run stand for the seventh wicket between Ravindra Jadeja (77) and MS Dhoni (50), who both came together with India at 92/6 and took them right to the doorstep of a final. Then came that Martin Guptill direct hit, and Dhoni was short of the crease. And that run-out, in some fans' minds, turned Dhoni into a villain.
But hold on a second, and I say this with full respect: India had already almost lost that match when Henry took down the top order, and Dhoni and Jadeja were the ones who pulled them back from the dead. It is only because it ended in heartbreak that the memory sticks to the last ball, not the first over.
And that is exactly the difference today. In 2019 India had Dhoni and Jadeja, experienced and talented enough to stand tall in a crisis. Today? Not one batter in the lower or any other order could even take the team past 100. Only three players crossed single digits, and our Ruturaj Gaikwad could make only 5 as the whole team collapsed like a deck of cards.
Matt Henry ODI Record Since 2025: The Terror Mark Behind the Spell
Here is the thing, this is not a fluke. Since 2025 he has played 14 ODIs, taken 37 wickets at an average of 16.29, a strike rate of 19.6 and an economy of 4.97. That is a wicket every 20 balls or so, and at fewer than five an over!
He also now has four 4-plus wicket hauls against India in ODIs, in just 12 innings, which puts him level with Ravi Rampaul, Ajantha Mendis, Brett Lee and Aaqib Javed at the top of the list, and he got there faster than any of them.
And the cherry on top: India will probably be happy to hear that Henry will not be there for Sunday's decider, as he will join the ones preparing for the Tests against India coming up.
Now, the Uncomfortable Part for CSK
Here is where I need to be the party pooper. A few fans, after seeing this spell, have already started saying: "see, retain Henry for IPL 2027!"
Let me gently ask: have you forgotten IPL 2026? Henry was given the new ball in CSK's first three defeats and went for a frankly heroic 13-plus an over, as we wrote in our IPL 2026 bowling review, and then he was quietly never seen again after game three. He was dropped because he could not adjust to the pitches in India, not because anyone had a grudge against him.
Even in the two T20Is against India on this same tour, he was not that good: 57 runs in 3.4 overs without a wicket in the first one, and then a tight but wicketless 2 overs for 11 in the second. Then suddenly in the ODI he brought his best against India. See the pattern?
I am not saying he is a bad bowler. Clearly, he is a very good one, and that is probably the reason he was bought in the first place. Or maybe it was just the New Zealand quota, thanks to Stephen Fleming! I am saying open your eyes and look at the pitch and the situation. A pitch in New Zealand, with that seam movement and an Indian batting line-up chasing 334, is a very different thing from the pitches of the IPL, which are getting flatter and flatter every season.
On such pitches, a swing bowler gets hit to all corners, and it demands much more variation, even from a conditions-based swing bowler like Henry.
Don't believe me? Look at the numbers. The average run rate per over in the IPL has gone from 8.40 in 2022 to 9.77 in IPL 2026, and it has gone up every single year.
Even the best in the business felt it. Jasprit Bumrah went at just 6.48 an over in 2024 and 6.68 in 2025, but at 8.37 in 2026. Arshdeep Singh went at 10.21 and Trent Boult, a proper swing specialist like Henry, was hit at 11.63 an over in 2026. And Henry himself? 13.00 an over in his 10 overs this season, which is exactly what we saw.
The one who survived was Bhuvneshwar Kumar, who went at 7.95 an over and took 28 wickets in 2026. But he is also the proof of my point, because he did it with a bag full of variations, slower balls and yorkers, not only with swing, along with loads of IPL experience and the advantage of being an Indian who has been playing on these pitches since childhood.
Should CSK Retain Matt Henry for IPL 2027?
So here is where I believe. Matt Henry is a genuinely special bowler when the ball is talking, and today he showed us why India has been scared of him since that rainy morning in Manchester in 2019. Enjoy the spell, save the highlights, and send them to your RCB or MI fan friends if you want to ruin their evening.
But when the IPL 2027 retention talk starts, please judge him on the pitches he will have to bowl on for us, not the one he destroyed India on today. The 13-plus an over in yellow is a real number, and so is the run rate of a league that gets flatter every season. One brilliant afternoon in New Zealand is not a reason to forget a month at the wrong end of the scoreboard in the IPL.
If CSK keep him, they need a plan for the flat decks, not just hope. If they let him go, nobody should call it a crime, because he will keep ripping teams apart in international cricket anyway. Either way, I will be happy to see our boy bowl like this, just maybe not against India, and definitely not on a flat Chepauk pitch!
Stay healthy stay yellow.